I wrote a post about menu design last year. This focussed mostly on the guest’s needs. Following that, I received some questions about the science of menus from the restaurant’s point of view.
For restaurant owners and menu designers, here are my tips, thoughts, and researched ideas on how to design your menu. The aim is to craft menus that not only showcase your culinary offerings but also subtly guide your guests towards certain choices. It’s a fascinating blend of psychology, design, and business strategy that many diners are unaware of. In this post, I’ll pull back the curtain on the techniques restaurants use to influence your dining decisions through their menus.
The Psychology Behind Menu Design
When you sit down at a restaurant and open the menu, you’re not just looking at a list of dishes. You’re interacting with a carefully crafted tool designed to shape your choices and maximise the restaurant’s profits. It’s a form of gentle manipulation that most diners never notice.
The Golden Triangle
One of the most powerful techniques in menu design is the use of the ‘Golden Triangle’. This refers to the way our eyes typically move when we first look at a menu. We tend to start at the middle, then move to the top right corner, and finally to the top left. Savvy restaurateurs place their most profitable items in these areas to catch your attention first.
For example, at one of my favourite restaurants (I’ll call it Randal’s to save upsetting other fine places I frequent), they always position their signature dish – a high-profit item – right in the centre of the menu. It’s usually the first thing customers see, and it often influences their entire perception of the offerings.
The Power of Placement
Beyond the Golden Triangle, the placement of items throughout the menu is crucial. Randal’s often start the menu with a relatively low-priced item in the top left corner. This serves as an ‘anchor’ price, making subsequent items seem more reasonable by comparison.
As the guest moves through the menu, the prices gradually increase, saving some of our most expensive items for the middle sections where they’re less likely to cause sticker shock. Then, Randal’s menus often finish with another lower-priced item in the bottom right corner, leaving the customer with a final impression of affordability.
The Language of Menus
The way dishes are described can have a significant impact on sales. Randal’s is not just selling food; they’re selling an experience, a story, a moment of indulgence.
Evocative Descriptions
Instead of simply listing ‘Grilled Chicken Breast’, Randal’s might describe it as ‘Succulent Free-Range Chicken, Flame-Grilled to Perfection’. Studies have shown that using descriptive language can increase sales by up to 27%.
The Power of Nostalgia
Randal’s often uses nostalgic language to create an emotional connection. ‘Grandma’s Apple Pie’ or ‘Old-Fashioned Beef Stew’ can transport diners back to cherished memories, making them more likely to order these items.
Price Psychology
The way prices are presented can significantly influence purchasing decisions. It’s a delicate balance between maximising profits and maintaining the perception of value.
Charm Pricing
This is the practice of ending prices with .99 or .95. While it might seem outdated, it still works. A dish priced at £9.99 is perceived as significantly cheaper than one at £10, even though the difference is negligible.
Price Anchoring
By including a few high-priced items, Randal’s can make other expensive dishes seem more reasonable. For instance, a £25 steak might seem pricey until it is placed next to a £40 lobster dish.
Visual Design Elements
The visual aspects of a menu are just as important as the content. They guide the eye, create emphasis, and contribute to the overall dining experience.
Colour Psychology
Colours can evoke specific emotions and associations. Red and yellow stimulate appetite, which is why they’re so common in fast-food branding. In Randal’s, they use deep blues and greens to create a sense of luxury and sophistication.
Typography and Layout
The font choice and layout can significantly impact how a menu is perceived. Randal’s uses elegant, easy-to-read fonts and plenty of white space to create a sense of quality and allow each dish to stand out.
The Impact of Images
While high-end restaurants often avoid images altogether, strategic use of photos can be extremely effective in certain contexts.
Quality Over Quantity
When using images, ensure they’re high-quality and appetising. A study by Cornell University found that menus with pictures can increase sales of an item by up to 30%.
Menu Engineering
Menu engineering is the practice of analysing the profitability and popularity of menu items and using this data to design the menu.
The Menu Matrix
Randal’s categorise their dishes into four groups:
- Stars: High profitability and popularity
- Plowhorses: Low profitability but high popularity
- Puzzles: High profitability but low popularity
- Dogs: Low profitability and popularity
This helps them to decide which items to promote, which to redesign, and which to remove.
Balancing Act
The goal is to guide customers towards stars while finding ways to increase the profitability of the plowhorses. They might place a star dish next to a plowhorse to make the latter seem like better value, encouraging customers to ‘trade up’.
The Ethics of Menu Manipulation
I often grapple with the ethical implications of these techniques. While they’re widely used and accepted in the industry, it’s important to consider the line between influence and manipulation.
Transparency vs Profitability
I believe in transparency in selling practices. Menu design is part of the overall service – restaurants are curating an experience for their guests, not trying to trick them. The goal is to guide, not to deceive.
The Customer’s Perspective
It’s crucial to remember that ultimately, customers want to enjoy their meal and feel they’ve received good value. If menu design achieves this while also benefiting the restaurant, I consider that a win-win situation.
The Future of Menu Design
As technology evolves, so too does the art of menu design. Digital menus offer new opportunities for personalisation and real-time adjustments.
Dynamic Pricing
Digital menus allow for dynamic pricing based on factors like time of day, inventory levels, or even weather conditions. This could revolutionise how restaurants manage their offerings and pricing.
Personalisation
With the rise of loyalty programmes and data collection, we may soon see menus personalised to individual diners based on their past preferences and dietary requirements.
Crafting Your Menu Strategy
Whether you’re a restaurateur or simply a curious diner, understanding these techniques can be valuable.
For Restaurant Owners
If you’re in the industry, consider how you can ethically apply these principles to your menu. Remember, the goal is to create a positive experience for your guests while also running a successful business.
For Diners
As a diner, being aware of these techniques can help you make more informed choices. Don’t be afraid to ask questions about dishes or explore parts of the menu you might usually overlook.
The Bottom Line
Menu design is a powerful tool in the restaurant industry, blending art, science, and psychology. When done well, it creates a win-win situation: diners enjoy a curated experience that guides them towards dishes they’ll love, while restaurants can showcase their best offerings and maintain profitability.
As the landscape of the restaurant industry continues to evolve, one thing remains constant: the menu will always be a crucial touchpoint between the restaurant and its guests. Understanding its power and using it responsibly is key to creating memorable dining experiences.
References and Further Reading
- Wansink, B., Painter, J., & Van Ittersum, K. (2001). Descriptive menu labels’ effect on sales. Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly, 42(6), 68-72.
- Yang, S. S., Kimes, S. E., & Sessarego, M. M. (2009). Menu price presentation influences on consumer purchase behavior in restaurants. International Journal of Hospitality Management, 28(1), 157-160.
- Ozdemir, B., & Caliskan, O. (2014). A review of literature on restaurant menus: Specifying the managerial issues. International Journal of Gastronomy and Food Science, 2(1), 3-13.
- Pavesic, D. V. (2005). The psychology of menu design: Reinvent your ‘silent salesperson’ to increase check averages and guest loyalty. Hospitality Faculty Publications, 5.
- Kincaid, C. S., & Corsun, D. L. (2003). Are consultants blowing smoke? An empirical test of the impact of menu layout on item sales. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, 15(4), 226-231.
- How to use restaurant menu psychology to get more sales – WISK.ai
- The psychology of menu design: Influencing customer choices
- Menu Engineering: Using Psychology to Increase Profits
- Restaurant Menu Pricing: Strategies to Make Profitable Menus
- 8 Psychological Tricks of Restaurant Menus – Mental Floss
Leave a Reply